PDA

View Full Version : Who is the GREATEST FIGHTING GAME PLAYER of ALL-TIME?


TarkanX
12-10-2007, 01:43 PM
Fighting games, traditionally are one on one; you versus your opponent, and who ever wins, gets claim that they are better. Taken on a wider scale, tournaments start to appear, which creates questions such as "who is better better between one place and another." Sometimes, it is easy as going to the specific area and battling the local or coastal champion; sometimes, it is hard when the revered champion has quit the game altogether. Since 1991, fighting games have had some sort of organized competition around the globe, and for many, the question still remains... who is the best fighting game player of all-time?

To be in the name of the greatest player, you have to be dominant in at least one game, or a top tournament placer in multiple games. You have to do this with aggressive competition that is wanting to knock you out of your spot. Every tournament is a day where you are challenged for your right to be able to get that top spot. The best don't fold under pressure, they thrive in it; they'll adapt to many scenarios as quickly as possible. Every second is trying to out think the opponent, forcing them to play your way, or to play a way they don't like to play. Basically, you just have to win, and no one will question you, emotions aside.

Before I list the names, I want to make some notes; some players will be missing that should be on the list... I did this, because if I included all the top names, the list would be way too big. I'd rather just pick out the absolute best one, or a couple players from at least one game.

Lesser, more obscure games, while good, just don't have enough competitive support to justify a quality placing. There are players like Cigarbob and James Goddard who are considered the best in the world at WeaponLord, but the problem is that maybe 10-15 people in the whole world take it seriously (semi), and most of them are scattered around the globe.

Players who were top tournament placers in multiple games "should" get a higher consideration than players who were dominant in one game; the ability to play multiple games is a hard task (having to adjust and adapt each time, as well as beating or at least giving the dominant player a run for their money in tournaments); players who played a game with a heavy talent pool should get more "points" than players whose games talent pool isn't very high (example, Tomo Ohira during the height of SF2); players should get more "points" for being a top tournament placer, or dominant in a game that considerably has more depth than another game... I don't want the focus of this thread to turn into a debate about which game is deeper, so this part should probably be ignored/overlooked.

There are going to be some big name omissions, mostly because they come from a place like Latin America, or Southeast Asia, etc... where it is hard to get in reach with the players. There is huge talent for the SNK games (mostly KOF), and they are definitely world class, but because there is a lack of available information, I can't really put them anywhere, other than a footnote. It is especially hard for the early fighters (91-95), when the internet was limited (and not nearly as popular) compared to now.

Here are the names (list is NOT in order of rank, or alphabetical) and a few descriptions about the player (I'm not too familiar with a couple other scenes, so help out if I am missing something or made an error):

TOMO OHIRA: The best SF2 player in the western hemisphere. Played the game when its popularity was at its peak. Could Dragon Punch Chun-Li's low Roundhouse on reaction. Lost less than 5 tournaments between World Warrior, Champion Edition, and Hyper Fighting. Never did face international competition, but was said by Kuni Funada to be on the level with the absolute best Japanese players in the world.

GIAN: Considered by the top Japanese ST players to be the best in the nation. Came to EVO in 2005 and single handedly swept teams with some of the most elite players in the world. If there was a vote to name the best ST player in the world, this guy would probably get the most votes.

MIKE WATSON: Was ranked in the top 5 in the nation for SF2 for years, considered the best SFA1 player, and possibly the best SFA3 player in the nation. Very technical, little mistakes, slowly ticks away at the opponents defense. Possibly the greatest pure Street Fighter player in the western hemisphere.

ALEX VALLE: Arguably the greatest player of all-time. Dominated the national scene in the mid 90's to the early 2000's; has recently made a resurgence. The greatest SFA2 player of all-time, the first US SFA3 champion, consistent top ST player, Virtua Fighter 3 national champion, always great in any SF3 game, was the best at Tekken 3 and almost became a world champion at Tekken Tag. A beast in the Marvel series from 1998 to 2002, beating players who are still at high level in that game today.

JOHN CHOI: Always consistent, always challenging for number one in a tournament. He is great at any Street Fighter game (even 3s). Was a top Virtua Fighter player in the late 90s. Could easily be considered for one of the greatest players of all-time.

OHNUKI: One of the greatest players of all-time. Any game he plays, he will be great. SF2, CvS2, SFA2, SFA3, Virtua Fighter, vampire Savior, the list goes on. He has placed very high, won national championships, or is considered the best at these games.

DAIGO UMEHARA: The choice for fan favorite fighting game player. His style of play makes people always want to watch him, even when he loses. Is one of the best in the world at ST, 3s, CvS2, Vampire Savior, and at one time the best SFA3 and Guilty Gear player. Has somewhat fallen off, but is always still a threat to take the title in any game he pays seriously.

RICKY ORTIZ: A great player at anything he takes seriously. Marvel, CvS, 3s, Tekken, etc... doesn't need to spend a lot of time for a game to be great. Always finds a way to win, even when the odds are stacked.

BAS: The inventor of many crazy custom combos. Considered at one time to be the best SFA3, and CvS2 player in the world. His placings are sometimes inconsistent, but he is always a threat to take the title in any game he plays. Also, an excellent KOF 2002 player.

RYAN HART: The great UK champion. Proficient in games, such as Virtua Fighter, Tekken, 3s, and ST, to the point where he gives even the great players a run for their money, or even beats them.

VER: Considered the best SFA3 player in the world, in a time where the game might not be as popular as it used to be, new techniques and strategies are still learned in the game. is proficient with pretty much every character.

JUSTIN WONG: The current great fighting game champion. The greatest MvC2 player of all-time (Has not placed 1st in only 5 Marvel tournaments, all in the last few years, since the game came out in 2000). The definition of anything he touches turns to gold. Places high and wins tournaments in some games with good talent, even though he doesn't take them seriously. He beasts in games even fighting game fans have never heard of. Could easily be considered for the greatest player of all-time.

EDDIE LEE: The first great East Coast player. At a time when fighting games in the United States were about California, he came on to the scene and became a top placer in any game he took seriously. The greatest MvC1 player of all-time, was a top SF3 placer, and Alpha placer.

KO: Considered to be the best 3s player in the world. He has the ability to use many characters at a high level. When someone mentions a character in 3s, the next best user would be considered for him.

AMIR: A beast at 3s, and at one time, the best in the nation. Is also very good at CvS2, 3s, and won an ST tournament with many great ST players in it.

TOKIDO: The king of cheap. His style of play is not liked, but it cannot be denied that he is one of the greatest players ever. Anything he touches, he will be come a top tournament placer, and even win tournaments. These include: SF2, SFA, 3s, CvS2, Virtua Fighter, Samurai Shodown. I'm not sure about this quote, but one of the good players has said that there are "4 kings" in the Japanese fighting game world, and he is one of them.

ARTURO SANCHEZ: Rose to prominence during the MvC1 era. Is very good at other games, such as the Alpha series, SF2, CvS2, 3s, and now recently, Arcana Heart.

JERON: Proficient at anything he touches. SF2, SFA, SFEX, CvS2, and other obscure games that might not get looked at as much.

MOE: Possibly the greatest UMK3 player of all-time. Played the game when the competition was still hot.

HANZO_HASASHI: The best UMK3 player in Venezuela, an area where the competition is still high, compared to other places in the world.

JASON WILSON: The greatest MK2 player of all-time, and is also proficient in other games, such as most Street Fighter games.

BUNBUN MARU: A champion in the early Virtua Fighter days. His style and personality was well liked by many people. He doesn't play as much anymore, but he can still beast.

CHIBITA: Considered to be the greatest Virtua Fighter player of all-time. His style of play is loved by many casual players. Wins tournaments or places high where the settings are single elimination, and the tournament entries have reached 30,000 for a national tournament. Has been a beast for the last 10 years.

SANFORD KELLY: Was a Tekken player in the beginning. He is mostly known for Marvel, but he is very proficient at many fighters, including CvS2, SFA2, and other obscure games.

ZAZZAMAN: Old School UK beast. Was the best at SF2, early Tekken, and early King of Fighters before he quit. He recently has came back and wants to beat into people how good he is.

KEN HOANG: The greatest Melee player of all-time. In his prime, he was just about unstoppable. Playing a game where the tournament entrees out number other fighting games in the United States. Has probably won more money than any fighting game player.

ISAI: The greatest Smash 64 player of all-time, and is considered top 10 in the world at Melee.

KOREAN DJ: Made a splash into the Smash scene, by becoming very good and placing in tournaments rather quickly. He is considered to be top 5 in the world currently.

OGAWA: Considered to be the best Guilty Gear player in the world.

KINDEBU: Probably the best CvS2 player in the world, but is known more to be proficient at anything he touches. Fist of the North Star, Alpha 3, King of Fighters, etc...

MAGO: A natural talent, where anything he plays, he will become very good at. Has placed very high, and has won in a few SBOs.

PERFECT LEGEND: Considered to be the best Dead or Alive player in the world. Makes the most money out of any fighting game player on a per year basis.

CROW: The two time Tekken 5 world champion. Also very good in other games, such as 3s, and CvS2.

ASIANHITLER: A natural talent where he can play the game for 2-3 days and become a beast. If he gets his hands on the game, he will become a top placer, or win tournaments.

JASON COLE: Very good Street Fighter player. Utilizes Dhalsim to the fullest, even in games where the character not be as proficient. Won national championships in ST in 2001, and 2002. Very good Alpha player.

JASON NELSON: Became very good when ST came out. Consistently placed high or won tournaments in ST, A2, A3, CvS1, CvS2.

YUKINOSE: One of the best Guilty Gear players in the world.

NIGA: Has won two SBOs in two different games. Guilty Gear Accent Core, and Melty Blood.

JANG IKSU: The greatest Tekken Tag Tournament player of all-time. Rarely messed up his execution, always on point. Retired a little too soon.

QUDANS: Was considered to be the best T5 player and T5DR player in the world. Came to EVO 2005 and destroyed the competition.

MAINSTREET RYU: Probably the current best player in the world at T5DR, he's only in his teens... I think.

ARARIO: Has been taking 1st place in national T5DR tournaments.

XIAOHAI: Won KOF98 at SBO 2007, to stake his claim as the best player in the world at the game, a game that is probably the most played around the world.

ABRAHAM: Probably the best KOF2K2 player in Mexico, which probably has the best 2K2 scene in the world.

RUU: Consistent to tournament placer in heavy technical games such as Guilty Gear, Melty Blood, and Arcana Heart.

MINT: Same as above.

STEVE HARRISON: If he plays a game, he's probably going to be very good at it. Very good at CvS2, Guilty Gear, Soul Calibur, and other obscure games that he doesn't even need to play.

KAORU: The world King of Fighters XI champion, won the title at SBO 2006.

JOP: Dominated Tekken Tag when it was at its peak. Still very good in T5DR.

MARN: A natural talent, doesn't have to put a lot of time into games to get really good. Top 5 Guilty Gear player on the continent for the last few years. Has been placing well in other games such as 3s.

The Granby
12-10-2007, 01:52 PM
All around? Nuki

Am I slightly biased because he pwns at VF too? Yes

shoo
12-10-2007, 01:57 PM
RUU: Consistent to tournament placer in heavy technical games such as Guilty Gear, Melty Blood, and Arcana Heart.

MINT: Same as above.

you just got lazy :razz:

-BF-
12-10-2007, 01:59 PM
Jay "Viscant" Snyder

Khiempossible
12-10-2007, 02:01 PM
Niga, cause that's the best name ever.

bellreisa
12-10-2007, 02:10 PM
Korean DJ, a proficient Melty Blood player :V

evilj
12-10-2007, 03:03 PM
Jang Ik Su-The only person on that list AFAIK, undefeated in his prime before he went to army. Nigga had one fucking eye.

One eyed Fighting Gamer=Reflex of the Gods

box
12-10-2007, 03:06 PM
For all-around ... I'd have to say Justin Wong.

MvC2, 3S, CvS2, ST... Who else has placed top 8 at EVO in all of those games.

MIKE WATSON: Was ranked in the top 5 in the nation for SF2 for years, considered the best SFA1 player, and possibly the best SFA3 player in the nation. Very technical, little mistakes, slowly ticks away at the opponents defense. Possibly the greatest pure Street Fighter player in the western hemisphere.

I'm not sure if he's the best SFA3 player in the nation. I thought that distinction went to John Choi.

P. Gorath
12-10-2007, 03:06 PM
buktooth

orka
12-10-2007, 03:09 PM
umehara

R | C
12-10-2007, 03:22 PM
According to SRK member Sanchez,

Daigo's half Mexican brother is the absolute best:

Diego Umejuarez.

:rofl:

MAGUS1234
12-10-2007, 03:28 PM
^^^lol!!

SwmmrManShen
12-10-2007, 03:31 PM
ive heard that kuroda has a beastly chun, just plays Q for the hell of it

4649
12-10-2007, 04:13 PM
i don't think Jang Iksu was actually missing an eye, I thought he was just blind in one eye

Chibita is a legend from VF3 era, VF4 era arguably was dominated by Homestay. i'm not sure when Ohsu appeared but he's up there too. Chibita and his team took SBO but Fuudo won Kakutou Shinseiki by himself AND beat Homestay, Ohsu, Yanaga, and Itazan in exhibition matches like right after that, so I think him and Chibita might be very comparable, although Chibita seems more creative where Fuudo takes less risk

also for Soul Calibur 2 era i think its a tossup between Mick, Aris, Dan the Nightmare, Dekka Chou ( Japan - he got scraped at SBO in SC3 this year, sadly, the whole crowd was behind him too )

i'm not sure about Daigo being the best at Guilty Gear at one point, didnt Miu teach him Sol or something? all i know is Daigo ran Vampire Savior pretty much the entire time it was out. early Guilty Gear i think basically belonged to Yukinose, Melty Blood too

Humbag
12-10-2007, 04:45 PM
Kuroda and someone else (forgot) are considered to be the best all around 3s players ever.

Marn and SteveH up there? They are both REALLY good but not the level of some of those.

I can see Marn for US GG along with JuicyG, Flash, Elven, and Blacksnake.

My vote goes to Kokujin! DUDLEY!!!!

Silks
12-10-2007, 05:13 PM
also for Soul Calibur 2 era i think its a tossup between Mick, Aris, Dan the Nightmare, Dekka Chou ( Japan - he got scraped at SBO in SC3 this year, sadly, the whole crowd was behind him too )


Floe

Anyhow, of ALL TIME?! Fighting game history has only mattered for what, 16 years now? Come on dude

McRomes
12-10-2007, 05:16 PM
After really all this thinking,I'd have to say Justin Wong.

Being THE best in a game like MvC2 is good enough,but he places top in almost anything he touches..............

Alzarath
12-10-2007, 05:26 PM
Where's Yipes? Craziest MSP ever imo.

G.O.T
12-10-2007, 05:30 PM
It sounds like a tie between Ohnuki and Justin Wong to me.

FistofFury2000
12-10-2007, 05:40 PM
It's a little known fact that Michael Jordan is also the best fighting game player of his time. Dominating people in Yie-Ar Kung Fu and Street Fighter 1.

DevilJin 01
12-10-2007, 05:45 PM
Angry Black Harrison!!!

FistofFury2000
12-10-2007, 05:46 PM
Then there's Fedor Emelianenko. Who will beat the snot out of people if he loses in fighting game. So people are afraid to win against him, so they let him win.

FistofFury2000
12-10-2007, 05:48 PM
and last but not least, Mike Chaos and the Dark Prince. For they strike fear into people's heart by their crazy trashtalk.


i kid i kid.

Harem
12-10-2007, 06:12 PM
i don't think Jang Iksu was actually missing an eye, I thought he was just blind in one eye

Chibita is a legend from VF3 era, VF4 era arguably was dominated by Homestay. i'm not sure when Ohsu appeared but he's up there too. Chibita and his team took SBO but Fuudo won Kakutou Shinseiki by himself AND beat Homestay, Ohsu, Yanaga, and Itazan in exhibition matches like right after that, so I think him and Chibita might be very comparable, although Chibita seems more creative where Fuudo takes less risk

also for Soul Calibur 2 era i think its a tossup between Mick, Aris, Dan the Nightmare, Dekka Chou ( Japan - he got scraped at SBO in SC3 this year, sadly, the whole crowd was behind him too )

i'm not sure about Daigo being the best at Guilty Gear at one point, didnt Miu teach him Sol or something? all i know is Daigo ran Vampire Savior pretty much the entire time it was out. early Guilty Gear i think basically belonged to Yukinose, Melty Blood too
It was Masa, not Miu.

Also, Mint up there? lawlz

Mr. Mamation
12-10-2007, 06:23 PM
Angry Black Harrison!!!

i was surprized to see him but its kinda cool

goodm0urning
12-10-2007, 06:32 PM
I don't know about the all-time greatest, since there are so many different fighting games and so many different types of players. But I will say that my FAVORITE player of all time is Alex Valle. His offense-based style is every bit as captivating as any Daigo comeback YouTube video, and during the days of Alpha, there was nobody better. He's one of the few players I'd be terrified to compete against, simply because of the psychological pressure he lays on his opponents.

And, of course, Daigo himself, the one-time arch rival of Alex. He's responsible for so many great moments in SF history, and not all of them involve something as paltry as parrying every hit of Chun Li's SAII.

orochizoolander
12-10-2007, 06:41 PM
Best overall fighting game player of all time is a 3way tie between wong, daigo, n valle.

quiche
12-10-2007, 06:45 PM
Gotta second Viscant.

None of those other guys have black vests.

...seriously.

dereklearnslow
12-10-2007, 06:49 PM
Wow you mentioned Moe of UMK3 fame. I used to play with that fool at Friars and the local comic shop around here, both now closed.

4649
12-10-2007, 08:01 PM
Floe



yeah i forgot about Floe, he was beasting

also how come Amir is up there and no Pyrolee :confused:

DS
12-10-2007, 08:12 PM
While I do like the idea of this thread, there are just too many names on that list that are game specific. I mean, just look at Bas. He's good, but CvS2 is his true claim to fame. Then you got guys like Sanford, Justin, Valle and Choi that are good at every game they touch. I would definitely re-group it if I had my way with the thread.

But yeah, I'm just gonna be biased and go with Daigo. The man defies 50/50 and makes risk/reward situations look like nothing.

Leebee Link
12-10-2007, 08:17 PM
valle, buk and daigo.

4649
12-10-2007, 08:30 PM
While I do like the idea of this thread, there are just too many names on that list that are game specific. I mean, just look at Bas. He's good, but CvS2 is his true claim to fame. .

wasn't his main game Alpha 3 before that though?
i thought he was big for innovating V-Gouki stuff, like didnt he invent the demon flip into otg fierce grab VC?
which i imagine was sometime after that first alpha 3 national japan had, maybe someone can correct me timeline-wise

TarkanX
12-10-2007, 09:07 PM
I was hoping this thread wouldn't turn to this...

This thread isn't to list top players! There are a whole bunch of threads like that. This thread is to list the BEST player EVER; not who has potential, not who is the best at a certain game, not who you're favorite player is, but the best EVER. I know I forgot some names, but if you guys read the thread, I said I didn't put them in, because the list would be way too big. Please, this thread has a lot of potential in it, a lot more potential than wish lists or "what is your favorite game".

I'm not sure if he's the best SFA3 player in the nation. I thought that distinction went to John Choi.

Yeah, Choi was the best in SFA3 for a few years before it stopped getting played in tournaments. I just go by the latest results, although Choi could easily be considered as the best in the nation.


Chibita is a legend from VF3 era, VF4 era arguably was dominated by Homestay. i'm not sure when Ohsu appeared but he's up there too. Chibita and his team took SBO but Fuudo won Kakutou Shinseiki by himself AND beat Homestay, Ohsu, Yanaga, and Itazan in exhibition matches like right after that, so I think him and Chibita might be very comparable, although Chibita seems more creative where Fuudo takes less risk

also for Soul Calibur 2 era i think its a tossup between Mick, Aris, Dan the Nightmare, Dekka Chou ( Japan - he got scraped at SBO in SC3 this year, sadly, the whole crowd was behind him too )

i'm not sure about Daigo being the best at Guilty Gear at one point, didnt Miu teach him Sol or something? all i know is Daigo ran Vampire Savior pretty much the entire time it was out. early Guilty Gear i think basically belonged to Yukinose, Melty Blood too

I'm not as familiar with some other scenes, so thanks for helping out. I didn't mean to say that Daigo was the best at Guilty Gear at one point, but he was definitely a top player. I was in a rush, since I had to leave for work.


Kuroda and someone else (forgot) are considered to be the best all around 3s players ever.

Marn and SteveH up there? They are both REALLY good but not the level of some of those.

I can see Marn for US GG along with JuicyG, Flash, Elven, and Blacksnake.

Again, I just threw a list up there. They might not be the absolute best, but they are both really talented, and it wouldn't take long for them to learn a game and beast in it... that's a sign of greatness.

Anyhow, of ALL TIME?! Fighting game history has only mattered for what, 16 years now? Come on dude

16 years is more than enough time to determine who the best ever is. Do you think we should wait 20 more years? no offense, but if a sports player whose played for that long usually has their career examined, then why not fighting games.

also how come Amir is up there and no Pyrolee

I only wanted to name a few players for each game. Amir and Pyro are on the same level in 3s, but Pyro only plays one game, while Amir is very good in multiple games with good talent backing the games.

While I do like the idea of this thread, there are just too many names on that list that are game specific. I mean, just look at Bas. He's good, but CvS2 is his true claim to fame. Then you got guys like Sanford, Justin, Valle and Choi that are good at every game they touch. I would definitely re-group it if I had my way with the thread.

Yeah, this is a hard task, but with effort, it is doable. This hasn't been done before; what is there to lose?


I hope I don't have to redo the first post, took me a few hours just to make that post.

Master Chibi
12-10-2007, 09:18 PM
KOREAN DJ: Made a splash into the Smash scene, by becoming very good and placing in tournaments rather quickly. He is considered to be top 5 in the world currently.Is also a proficient Melty Blood player.

No he's not.

:rofl:

Harem
12-10-2007, 09:29 PM
No he's not.

:rofl:

2A, 6C is some top tier shit yo

VPT
12-10-2007, 09:31 PM
Hey great job on compiling all of that information. Sanford started with Tekken? Really? Wow.

It's so easy and tempting to vote for Daigo, but I would have to go with Tokido as an overall competitor due to his ability to adapt.

Zal
12-10-2007, 09:49 PM
i can't believe you didn't mention Daigo in all of that, has probably played in the most famous of all street fighter matches ever.

Dencore
12-10-2007, 10:00 PM
Me of course.

The Juice
12-10-2007, 10:01 PM
Valle no question:


No other player on that list can claim to be world class in both 2d AND 3d games at one point or another but Valle, Not Daigo, Not Justin...no one can claim that.

VPT
12-10-2007, 10:07 PM
Valle no question:


No other player on that list can claim to be world class in both 2d AND 3d games at one point or another but Valle, Not Daigo, Not Justin...no one can claim that.Technically, Wong is a top Tekken player, Ohnuki and Tokido are top VF5 players, and a lot of other 2D players have a decent level of proficiency in 3D games. However, none have probably risen to the 3D championship level that Valle has, except maybe Ohnuki.

Insom
12-10-2007, 10:11 PM
Jay "Viscant" Snyder

The Electrifying One
12-10-2007, 10:11 PM
Ryan Hart.

Just because I can then say I have clocked a win on the best ever.

ParryPerson.
12-10-2007, 10:12 PM
I vote Jay "The Bacon" "Viscant" Snyder as the best video game player ever.

He signed Storm cards for money. Step back.

UltraDavid
12-10-2007, 10:12 PM
Steve Harrison? Steve's a very good player and always does really well in CvS2 and I hear he's good in SNK and GG, buuuut I go even with him in 3S and beat him in ST. Anyone I go even with or beat in any game isn't in the conversation for best fighting game player ever.

I don't know Japan as well as I know America, so for best American player ever my votes go to Valle, Choi, and Wong.

BobSmack
12-10-2007, 10:21 PM
Dylan, Dylan, Dylan, Dylan, and Dylan.

Mizuki
12-10-2007, 10:31 PM
According to SRK member Sanchez,

Daigo's half Mexican brother is the absolute best:

Diego Umejuarez.

:rofl:

DIEGOOOOOOO


And what the fuck? KoreanDJ a "proficient MB player?"


hahahahahahaha

Why don't you just put me up for Melty?

megaultrasuper
12-10-2007, 10:50 PM
My vote is for Alex.

No one to my knowledge was as dominant in as many games for as long as he was when he was active.

I think he got first or second in a all games at B4? Correct me if I'm wrong.

Additionally, I think players that have dominated on multiple continents should be highly regarded. In this respect I think the winner is Daigo, since he has won major tournaments in Japan, US, and UK.

taiji
12-10-2007, 11:08 PM
valle

combofiend should have been on that list too

JustinW
12-11-2007, 12:34 AM
I think flashmetroid should be on it. He would kill majority of the players on the list if its a race of 5 games. His execution is tight. He has proven himself in ggxx as s class and all the other fighters he is at least B class.

AmbiguousCrosup
12-11-2007, 12:39 AM
Valle. No Doubt.

FlashMetroid
12-11-2007, 12:44 AM
Niga, cause that's the best name ever.

Nah son im gonna have to give that to Obiwan-fashobi

I think flashmetroid should be on it. He would kill majority of the players on the list if its a race of 5 games. His execution is tight. He has proven himself in ggxx as s class and all the other fighters he is at least B class.

lolz

Shodokan123
12-11-2007, 01:40 AM
Best fighting game player ever is hard to say... because alot of the great players only played certain games.

Overall: nuki, daigo, justin, random people in arcades in japan (from what i have heard from people some of their casual players just BEAST the top tourny players)

Robust
12-11-2007, 02:04 AM
1st. Mike Watson. Easy.

2nd. Justin Wang

3rd. John Choi

4th Cambofiend

























































999th. Alex Valle

Worthless
12-11-2007, 02:15 AM
Only one i know personally is Korean DJ.He's a pretty cool guy overall really chill and everything,and even though he rocked the shit out of me In MBAC,MY REMY STILL BEATS HIS CHUN. /flexes :lol:

epsilon_
12-11-2007, 02:19 AM
in the us, justin overall. valle, choi, ricky, eddie lee, watson arturo...all those guys are in the discussion too.

ever? nuki and daigo probably. imo

megafighter
12-11-2007, 02:51 AM
My vote goes to JWong as well. MvC2 was arguably the most competitive game ever, even if you count only the US competition, and he took it like cakes. Then he plays other games without that much practice and years later than top world players and manages to get top 2 (3rd Strike), top 3(CvS2), or top 5 (T5, ST) at Evo. When he plays on EC, its much more evil. I once read about he winning 12 tourneys at a single MWC, including Puzzle Fighter. He wins tourneys or MMs in games he doesn't even play. IMO, nobody can compare.

My second would be Nuki. Daigo has a lot more hype, but Nuki has more results in more diff games and, like JWong, can be a monster even in games where he is not a specialist, like ST. If only he could pull such an miracle at MvC2...

3rd would be Valle. Valle is a monster. He was among the top world players in many many diff games, including such as MvC2 (you read it right), Tekken, and of course every SF to date. Plus, Valle scared Daigo away from Evo by preventing him from make money in his 2 best games.

4th would be Tokido IMO, also because of versatility and incredible adapting skills. Not so sure if he belongs in this God Tier, but last Evo sure elevated his stock.


2nd or top tier IMO would have Daigo, Choi, and then there's too hard to point them out. Everybody listed is great, but those are my picks.

SNAAAAKE
12-11-2007, 03:20 AM
all around its easily justin. everyone else got their own game but still not "all around" enough.

"EVER" would be Daigo..give him any game and he will just learn it overnight

orochizoolander
12-11-2007, 03:20 AM
IMO placing well at tourneys in multiple games outweighs those who dominate undisputedly in only 1 game. With that said i don't know how anyone could dispute daigo, wong, choi, n valle as the top4 overall players unless there are others who are just as proficient in multiple games as them that i'm not aware of.

quiche
12-11-2007, 04:21 AM
Only one i know personally is Korean DJ.You know Jay Snyder.

And I mean, don't we ALL know Jay Snyder?

Why is he still not on that list?

True Viscant Fact: He is also one of the world's top fleshlight players.

...seriously.

Radiantsilvergun3
12-11-2007, 04:43 AM
Balle is my favorite player to see play. He's dominated in anything with the name Sftreet Fighter on it and a few games without. i give him my Vote. Besides gotta rep the homeland.

Daigo is great to and Choi is awesome to.

Infested Jester
12-11-2007, 05:50 AM
For an area of expertise, I'd have to go Jang Iksu in TTT. Going undefeated in TTT, at it's prime and after, in Korea for years is hardcore. Plus the dude could only see out of one eye.

Overall I'd say Justin or Daigo. Too many wins in too many games, over too long a period of time.

xS A M U R A Ix
12-11-2007, 10:12 AM
On sheer fame right now, I'm sure Justin or Daigo would win. Lots of really good players out there though so I can't really say any particular person is BEST EVER.

And I think I agree with flash being on there, atleast as far as US GG goes, he's one of the top players. I mean hell, Marn's up there, so why not him? >_<

Saotome Kaneda
12-11-2007, 10:23 AM
Why are you nominating guys that aren't on the top of the single game they're best at? Or guys that aren't top in all the games they play? Or guys that are only good in one game? What is the point of this thread?

xS A M U R A Ix
12-11-2007, 10:35 AM
Why are you nominating guys that aren't on the top of the single game they're best at? Or guys that aren't top in all the games they play? Or guys that are only good in one game? What is the point of this thread?

dick sucking / band wagoning?

/shrug

SaBrE
12-11-2007, 10:43 AM
i agree with sk. this thread makes no sense. best fighting game players of all time should be who was most dominant in the realm of competitive fighters, not who was most dominant in a single game.

with that said, in america, no one comes close to watson, valle, justin, and choi, and an honorable mention to ricky ortiz. in japan, it would be daigo and nuki. no one else comes close

Chachi
12-11-2007, 11:55 AM
hay you forgot me.

Actually I'll go with Valle, Watson and Choi in US, and Daigo, Mago, and Kindevu in Japan.

FlashMetroid
12-11-2007, 12:01 PM
Why are you nominating guys that aren't on the top of the single game they're best at? Or guys that aren't top in all the games they play? Or guys that are only good in one game? What is the point of this thread?

Damn I thought I was pretty damn good at alot of games but damn I thought I would be top in at least my game.....but I guess since random nobody who obviously knows nothing about GG said so then I guess im wrong

Anyway this thread is retarded and pretty much has become an OG dick riding contest

If this thread is about over all performance in games and not a single game then why the fuck is Watson being mentioned so much...actually 90% of those names are mention for a small amount of games most of them being different versions on one game

If this thread is truly about the best fighting game player then watson and 50 more of those guys dont belong there the only ones that do are

Nuki
Justin
Diago
Combofiend
Choi

m121akuma
12-11-2007, 12:15 PM
Valle and Choi, no doubt.

DevilJin 01
12-11-2007, 12:17 PM
Damn I thought I was pretty damn good at alot of games but damn I thought I would be top in at least my game.....but I guess since random nobody who obviously knows nothing about GG said so then I guess im wrong

Anyway this thread is retarded and pretty much has become an OG dick riding contest

If this thread is about over all performance in games and not a single game then why the fuck is Watson being mentioned so much...actually 90% of those names are mention for a small amount of games most of them being different versions on one game

If this thread is truly about the best fighting game player then watson and 50 more of those guys dont belong there the only ones that do are

Nuki
Justin
Diago
Combofiend
Choi

I'll vote for you.

Bacardi
12-11-2007, 12:43 PM
MvC2 was arguably the most competitive game ever, even if you count only the US competition


Local vf tournies in japan pull in more entries than mvc2 does at evo

umthrfkr
12-11-2007, 12:55 PM
I think flashmetroid should be on it. He would kill majority of the players on the list if its a race of 5 games. His execution is tight. He has proven himself in ggxx as s class and all the other fighters he is at least B class.

i too vote for flashmetroid. seeing as how eric v isnt on that list anywhere.

Zal
12-11-2007, 12:59 PM
from my perspective here's how it goes:

Alex Valle
John Choi
Daigo
Justin Wong

these are the fighters that have really changed the game

Valle is a beast at any game he touches
Choi can adapt to ANY stituation, which almost makes him better than Valle
Daigo is just a beast, and changed up the whole North American 3s game,
And last but not least is JWong who is a completely and totally dominating player. His work in MVC2 is just astonishing

These are my personal favorites. if if had to boil it down to one vote i think i'd throw mine for valle or choi, they have been in this for a LLOOONG time and their dominant playing won't be going away any time soon

Kayin
12-11-2007, 01:04 PM
KoreanDJ sucks at Melty Blood.

DJTPC
12-11-2007, 01:22 PM
Most known in Europe: Daigo and Valle (by far I think)

Battosai
12-11-2007, 01:29 PM
You forgot one of the greatest SF2 players of the western hemiphere (sunnyvale, CA) besides Tomo(maybe 2nd to him) is
the legend Thomas Osaki(WW, CE, HF) his Guile was perfect in those games nearly untouchable, and he said in a interview that the only way someone could beat his Guile is they would have to take his controls away from him. Also, he never made the same mistake twice. He went on to Super SF2 (Beta Gamma Tournament) and ST and retired, but he did make a comeback in EVO 2k2. I was very fourtunite to face against the legend on ST casualy at EVO, plus it was very cool to get to talk to him(got a lot of good tips) . He was a very ruthless player and hands down the best in my opinion besides Tomo.

evilj
12-11-2007, 02:10 PM
For US, Valle and Justin Wong easily. All the other guys only dominated sf or 2d games, valle at one point was considered the best tekken tag player in america and even by the end of the game's life he was probably top 10. Even JOP said back then Valle on SHGL controls was the best player hands down.

You might say who cares about tekken but honestly evo was started because of the huge sf and tekken communities uniting.

It would have been nice to see Valle vs Justin at Evo.

Bobbypigo
12-11-2007, 02:27 PM
I vote for me.