Pizza Topping Tier List


#1

Alright so it’s been a while and everyone has had tried out what they wanted to. Japan has made their opinions known, and all of the match-ups and pairings are all but played out. So I think its fine time we established a tier list, just so we can all know where everything stands.

Just because you main it doesn’t make it good; no spamming how much you think Anchovies are S-tier.
Also just because something is low tier doesn’t mean it isn’t worth trying. Who knows: you might be the one to show us all how wrong we all are about Pineapple.

God tier
Cheese
Tomato Sauce

Top tier
Pepperoni
Extra Cheese

Mid tier
Chicken
Green Peppers
Onions
Sausage
Ham
Bacon

Low tier
Mushrooms
Meatballs
Sliced Tomatoes
Garlic
Spinach

Bottom Tier
Olives
Jalapenos
Anchovies
Pineapples


The Pizza Thread :D
Pizza Toppings
CT Thread | Weekly Thursdays 7pm Fire & Dice Games Milford CT
#2

My cousin likes getting pinapple pizza, then topping it with red chili powder and mayo. I was like “WTF” but it actually wasn’t too bad. I guess we could take in account seasonings to help out some toppings in the tier list, since they might move some stuff around.


#3

In my view seasonings are like Tron in MvC2: they may make some of the bottom tier usable, but they’re still bottom tier at the end of the day


#4

WTF how do you not have Spinach in Top tier at the very least?? in Theory it has 9-1 match-ups again cheese, pepperoni and all the other mid tiers sure no one is winning with it but that’s only because the execution barrier is too high. But still given a few more months and depending how the meta-game evolves Spinach could easily end up God Tier by the end of this game’s lifespan. Also fuck Tomato sauce shit is so beyond broken


#5

http://s5.photobucket.com/albums/y171/hubcapsignstop/animated gifs/?action=view&current=sicilian2.jpg
all else is not pizza, but a cheap imitation
i an from Schenectady.

edit:
found it/real:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/windy_valley/4235419740/
(Perreca’s; closest to Grandma’s; real Sicilian)


#6

This tier list must be wrong. I usually play low tier, but here I find myself only using God Tier and S-Tier all day.

Capcom, nerf pepperoni and extra cheese so that I don’t feel bad using them all the time.


#7

God Tier
Pepperoni
Mushrooms
Jalapenos

Everything else Tier


#8

Phoenix Tier
Pepperoni

Top tier
Sausage
Ham
Bacon
Beef
Extra Cheese

Third Strike “Guess right three times and win” Tier
Onions
Sliced Tomatoes
Garlic
Chicken

Low tier
Green Pepper
Jalapenos
Spinach (Really its best match is 4-6 against Garlic, you have to be blind not to see this)

Hakan Tier
Olives
Anchovies
Pineapple (Entire board is 0-10 matches)
Mushrooms


#9

Hot Sauce


#10

What about the other “toppings” such as dried oregano, those AWESOME red pepper flakes, granulated garlic, grated parmesan, or freshly cracked black pepper?

Also, Sauce and Cheese shouldn’t be in a god tier by themselves. Sauce, cheese, and crust is what MAKES a pizza. It’s like saying “Sandwich filling tier list” and putting “bread” at the god tier.

As for my favorites, I’d put pepperoni in the god tier by itself. My favorite pizza is a pepperoni and mushroom pie from some of my local Brooklyn joints. Which is weird, because I generally don’t even like mushrooms all that much. I’d put up a large pepperoni and mushroom from Brooklyn up against any pizza, anywhere.

^_-;


#11

Why are anchovies bottom tier? I like anchovies.


#12

Pepperoni, sausage and bacon is the magic combo, folks. Little Caesar’s has this as their “Meat Trio” and it’s GOLD. It has actually spoiled me… a “meat lover’s” style pizza is only “alright” to me now if there is no bacon. As with so many other things in life… bacon is that magic ingredient that elevates things to the next level. It’s almost not even fair to compare other toppings to this incredible combination.

On a sidenote… I still think people should probably be arrested for putting mayo on a pizza. That is sinful.


#13

Why are Jalapenos bottom tier? Is it too hot for you or something?


#14

Anchovies are god tier, which is why their banned.


#15

I miss Brooklyn pizza :frowning:
Trying to find good pizza in Vegas is like finding a needle in a haystack omg.


#16

How dare you people put pineapple and jalapenos on the bottom. For delivery pizza, pepperoni, pineapple and jalapenos makes for some tasty toppings.

As for the best kind of pizza topping? Avocado. Best avocado combination? Chicken, Bacon and Avocado.


#17

No white garlic sauce?! Dawgs…

  • Chicken, jalapenos, red onions, hot sauce, done.

#18

How can you guys not like pineapple? I’m not a big fan of it, but I don’t see how people can hate it.


#19

extra sauce,green pepper, red onion, ground beef, barbeque sauce on top, red chilli flakes on top
^nerf that shit now capcom, its to good.


#20

people are hating on pineapple and jalapenos? SMH IN DISGUST

only little kids (see home alone) eat cheese pizzas. Supreme Pizza all day! nothing beats Supreme