Living most of my life in Philly, it was Old English Pizza on 9th & Hunting Park Ave. Amazing stuff and good people too. Not sure if the same people still own it, but I can still remember the lady hitting me and my sister up w/ free slices on our walk from the bus stop after school.
Now I live in North Jersey and to be honest, the pizza here ain’t that great - don’t even get me started on the cheesesteaks. I work in Manhattan and if I want pizza I usually hit up Bravo Pizza in midtown not far from Times Square.
As for toppings I usually just get plain since 9/10 times the meat isn’t gonna be halal. If there is halal meat available I’ll mess w/ pepperoni. This dude I know makes a pizza w/ cheesesteak meat that’s pretty on point too.
You can also try getting hot sausage, cut it into slices and throwing it on a frozen pizza.