When SMB2 came out the phantos (2:53) and floating bird head (3:13) creeped me the fuck out and gave me nightmares. The panicky music didn’t help either lol. Seeing HIM/IT for the first time in Mulholland Drive gave me a good jolt too. Nothing makes my skin crawl more then the creepy piano music in Eyes Wide Shut. Dead Space 1 and especially 2 scared me countless times and maintain a very uncomfortable atmosphere throughout.
Admit your inner Chuckie Finster fear the man in the oatmeal box!